Timeless Italian Dining in the Heart of Roslyn

388 Willis Avenue | Roslyn

A Classic Seafood Spot in the Heart of Babylon

458 Fire Island Avenue | Babylon

A vibrant Italian hotspot known for dramatic décor, tableside specialties, and crowd-pleasing modern classics.

725 Merrick Ave | Westbury

A stylish Italian kitchen in Oyster Bay serving refined classics, fresh seafood, and expertly crafted cocktails in a warm, welcoming setting.

94 South St | Oyster Bay

A chic Garden City dining destination serving modern Italian cuisine, handcrafted cocktails, and upscale nightlife energy.

9 Nassau Blvd | Garden City

A stylish Italian hotspot known for upscale dishes, craft cocktails, and a lively, modern vibe.

569 Broadhollow Rd | Melville

Rustic Italian flavors and house-made pastas served in a warm, elegant Smithtown setting.

197 Terry Rd | Smithtown

Upscale Italian Dining with a Cozy Wine Bar Atmosphere in Amityville

184 Broadway | Amityville

A North Fork Italian Classic with Heart and Heritage

28350 Main Road | Cutchogue

Classic Italian with Heart in Farmingdale

10 Allen Blvd | Farmingdale

A Classic Italian Dining Experience Worth Savoring

1496 Northern Blvd | Manhasset

Warm, Wood-Fired Italian on the North Fork

13550 Main Road | Mattituck

Islip's Trendy Spot for Pizza, Pasta, and Craft Cocktails

517 Main St | Islip

A Warm Neighborhood Italian Spot With Classic Flavors & Family-Friendly Charm

304 Route 25A | Mount Sinai

Bold flavors, coal-fired tradition, and crowd-pleasing comfort.

137 Old Country Road | Carle Place

Small-Town Charm, Big Italian Flavor in Locust Valley

7b Birch Hill Road (The Plaza) | Locust Valley

Elegant Italian Dining in the Heart of Bellmore, NY

2520 Merrick Road | Bellmore

Coal-Fired Pizza and Italian Tradition in Rockville Centre

26 North Park Avenue | Rockville Centre

A Timeless Tradition in East Meadow

1580 Hempstead Turnpike | East Meadow

Classic Italian with a Neighborhood Heart in Sayville

100 South Main Street | Sayville

Elevated Italian Dining with a Familiar Feel

7903 Jericho Turnpike (Woodbury Village) | Woodbury

Elegant Italian Dining with a Contemporary Edge in Syosset

499 Jericho Turnpike | Syosset

Timeless Italian Dining with Heart in Westbury

1636 Old Country Rd | Westbury

Upscale European Café Vibes in the Heart of Garden City

13 Nassau Boulevard South | Garden City

Sophisticated Italian Dining with Heart in Mineola

348 East Jericho Tpke. | Mineola

Syosset’s Classic Italian Experience

352 Jericho Tpke | Syosset

Elevated Italian Dining at the Heart of Manhasset

2110 C Northern Blvd | Manhasset

Where sushi meets pasta and classic comfort gets a modern twist.

14 Broadhollow Rd. | Melville

Modern Italian Dining in the Heart of East Hampton

29 Newtown Lane | East Hampton

Casual pizzeria in Albertson serving reliable slices and comfort food.

815 Willis Avenue | Albertson

Reviewed by a Long Island Food Explorer who believes every neighborhood deserves a great Italian spot.

1203 Broadway | Hewlett

Homestyle Italian Comfort With a Warm, Welcoming Feel

301 Main Street | Islip

Wading River's Upscale Dining Destination

5720 Route 25A | Wading River

Authentic Italian Dining in Rockville Centre

12 North Park Avenue | Rockville Centre

Elevated Italian Dining in Bridgehampton

2402 Montauk Hwy | Bridgehampton

Eddie’s Pizza New Hyde Park: Home of the Iconic Bar Pie and Timeless Flavor

2048 Hillside Avenue | New Hyde Park